Skip to main content

📣 Join the Next Webinar "Cybersecurity 101: How to Protect Your Business in the Digital Age"

«  View All Posts

Frequently Asked Questions: Employee Handbook Edition

Contributor: Tabitha Aliano, PHR, HR Consultant

March 29th, 2024 | 5 min. read

By Tony Calavitta

Fact or  Fiction?

Your employee handbook should provide more answers than questions. FACT!

During our recent webinar, How to Build the Best Employee Handbook for Your Business, you hit us with a wide range of handbook questions to answer. FACT!

And now that the event is over, we probably won’t  take the time to answer them. FICTION!

In fact, we've doubled down on our commitment and have turned your questions into this article, designed to answer the most common questions employers have about all things related to employee handbooks.

So, keep reading to:

  • Learn about common handbook inquiries
  • Get actionable answers relevant to your handbook
  • And take the value of your employee handbook as a workplace resource to the next level

Employee handbook FAQs - Top questions, answered

If you watched our employee handbook webinar, you’ve got what it takes to turn your handbook into an effective workplace resource. 

Missed it? No worries! Access the webinar recording below to catch up on the essential insights you need to take your handbook to the next level.

Now, to further support you in this process, here are answers to the most frequently asked questions employers have about employee handbooks.

FAQ #1 - How should I update and maintain my employee handbook?

Incorporating new policies:

Employee handbooks are living documents, so you need to continuously add new policies to keep them current. Reasons to update your handbook include legal changes, shifts in company culture, adoption of new technologies, and the list goes on.

With this range of reasons in mind, the real challenge here isn't deciding whether to update your handbook, it's how to do it efficiently and effectively.

The secret to accomplishing this is having a structured process in place:

  1. First, you'll want to thoroughly assess your handbook regularly to identify any gaps or outdated information.

  2. Then, you’ll need to determine what specific policies will not only address these gaps but also reflect your company's specific needs.

  3. Finally, to ensure your handbook functions as a clear and consistent resource for employees, you’ll have to both integrate these changes into your existing handbook and communicate them to your team.

Easy enough, right?

With a defined workflow to guide how you manage modifications, keeping your employee current and compliant will be easier than ever.

Need to refine your employee handbook workflow? Download our FREE checklist for detailed directions on how to  take your employee handbook from standard to standout!

Frequency and timing of updates:

Want to maintain an effective employee handbook?

Then you better plan on reviewing and updating it annually.

But – a word of caution – if the regulatory environment of your business requires a more nuanced approach, you may need to do this more frequently. Indicators like new laws, law changes, organizational structure shifts, or the adoption of innovative technologies mean that your handbook may require updates before a yearly routine review.

Ensuring compliance and relevance:

Vigilance in monitoring law changes is key, especially in jurisdictions with rapidly evolving legal requirements.

To maintain a handbook that is both compliant and relevant, you should monitor legal developments closely, engage with HR professionals or legal counsel, and consider feedback from employees.

This proactive approach ensures that your handbook evolves in tandem with your company and benefits your business as a cornerstone of workplace guidance.

FAQ #2 - How should I navigate multi-state employment laws?

Single vs. state-specific handbooks:

If your business has a multi-state presence, deciding between a unified employee handbook or state-specific versions is a critical consideration.

And, go figure, there are pros and cons to either approach:

A single, unified handbook offers a clear advantage. It promises simplicity and consistency. However, it requires careful construction to ensure compliance with strict legal standards across all of the company's operating locations.

On the other hand, state-specific handbooks provide the benefit of tailored content that directly addresses the unique legal requirements of each separate jurisdiction. This approach, while potentially more effective, comes with the complexity and increased administrative burden of managing multiple versions.

Tailoring content to jurisdiction:

Customizing your handbook content to meet the legal requirements of each state in which your company operates is essential for both clarity and compliance. This might mean adjusting policies on leave, harassment, or wage and hour laws to reflect the necessary state-specific regulations.

Having clear, jurisdiction-specific policies, though, can help you prevent legal issues while ensuring that your employees understand their rights and obligations.

Put your employee handbook to the policy test, with our QUICK & INTERACTIVE quiz! Get your personalized results with applicable handbook insights in minutes.

FAQ #3 - How should I address handbook acknowledgment challenges?

Employee refusal to sign:

  Best case scenario: Signed, sealed, and delivered.

  Worst-case scenario: Your employee will not agree to sign your handbook.

Encountering an employee hesitant to sign a handbook acknowledgement can be a hurdle, but it also presents a valuable opportunity for open communication.

By taking the time to understand the reasons behind their refusal, you can gain valuable insights into potential areas of the handbook that may require clarification or even adjustment. Equally important is fostering an open line of communication throughout the process. This ensures that employees feel heard, understood, and comfortable raising any concerns they may have regarding the handbook or company policies.

Documentation and communication:

Let’s say that the above worst-case scenario happened:

Documenting an employee's refusal to sign, along with any discussions or attempts to address their concerns, is vital for legal protection and important to record-keeping. This documented record should be kept securely in the employee's personnel file.

But, again, the key to minimizing these situations lies in fostering a culture of open communication from the start. By implementing effective communication strategies, such as providing clear explanations of the handbook's purpose and the importance of acknowledgment, you can help mitigate employee hesitance while building a strong foundation of workplace transparency and mutual respect.

FAQ #4 - How should I handle employee handbook compliance for independent contractors?

Clarifying the contractor relationship:

Sure, independent contractors are partners in your company’s progress.

But, are they employees?

They aren’t classified as employees for the following reasons:

  • They don’t receive a W-2
  • They don’t have taxes withheld from their paycheck
  • They have more autonomy over their work schedule and responsibilities
  • They generally do not receive employee benefits as part of their compensation

This distinction between 1099 contractors and W-2 employees is a critical legal and operational consideration – and it also affects your employee handbook protocol.

Contractors should not be asked to sign the employee handbook. Why? This could blur the lines between their employee vs. contractor status.

Instead, you’ll need a separate document outlining the expectations and policies specific to independent contractors. This will provide them with clarity and you with legal protection.

Policy documentation for contractors:

Creating clear, concise policy documents for independent contractors ensures that expectations are set from the outset.

These documents can cover confidentiality, data security, and project-specific guidelines, providing a framework for a successful working relationship while maintaining their legal distinction from employees.

FAQ #5: How should I integrate arbitration agreements into employment documents?

Arbitration agreements in employment:

Given the choice between a courtroom battle or a boardroom discussion, which would you choose?

Arbitration agreements are increasingly common in today’s employment landscape. They offer an alternative, out-of-court approach to resolving workplace disputes.

This can streamline the conflict resolution process and potentially minimize litigation costs for both you and your employees.

So, yes, requiring an arbitration agreement – whether it’s in new hire paperwork or as a handbook inclusion – can be an effective way to mediate workplace conflict. However, implementing arbitration agreements effectively hinges on careful consideration and clear communication.

Legal considerations and employee acceptance:

The legal conditions surrounding arbitration agreements are complex and vary by jurisdiction.

When implementing an arbitration agreement, you need to make sure that it adheres to local regulations and are introduced in a manner that encourages acceptance is paramount.

Integrating agreements with employee handbook policies:

You should also consider the timing of presentation.

It is highly recommended to introduce these agreements on the first day of employment. Plus, you should also be ready to discuss the agreement's implications and benefits.

To learn more about employee handbook best practices, check out our comprehensive article, detailing today's most effective handbook strategies.

Take the next steps – Get help with your employee handbook!

And there you have it – fact over fiction, clarity over confusion!

FACT! We've journeyed through essential updates, navigated complexities of multi-state laws, and unlocked strategies for effective handbook acknowledgment, all fueled by your insightful questions. 

Your attention to employee handbook mastery shouldn’t end here!

FACT! The evolution of your employee handbook is an ongoing dialogue, one that thrives on continuous inquiry and adaptation. 

So, what's next?

Keep your questions coming! Whether you're pondering the latest legal updates, correcting content mistakes, or simply seeking to enhance your handbook's impact, we're here to dive deep and provide you with the answers you need.

Schedule a meeting with our team of experts today and transform your employee handbook into the ultimate resource it's meant to be.

FACT! Because when it comes to building the best employee handbook for your business, the only fiction is thinking you have to do it alone.  

compliance cta circle 400x400


Ready to elevate your employee handbook?

Schedule a Meeting


This article is not intended to be exhaustive nor should any discussion or opinions be construed as legal advice. Readers should contact legal counsel for legal advice.